A roadside repair brings the workplace to the vehicle, wherever it has broken down. That can mean working beside moving traffic, using lifting equipment on uneven ground and making decisions under pressure. For employers, those conditions make clear instructions and close attention to a worker’s experience particularly important.
A recent Health and Safety Executive (HSE) prosecution is a sobering reminder. Halford Commercial Fleet Services Limited, formerly The Lodge Tyre Company Limited, was fined £600,000 after pleading guilty to breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. At Warrington Magistrates’ Court on 3 November 2026, the company was also ordered to pay a £200 victim surcharge and £24,203 in costs.
On 2 August 2024, 21-year-old employee Niall Fawcett was replacing a blown-out tyre on a low-profile truck on the slip road at junction 7 of the M56 near Bowdon, Cheshire. The HSE said the truck was understood to have slipped from the bottle jack being used to raise it while he was working beneath it. He died from his injuries.
The HSE found that the risks of replacing a blown-out tyre on a low-profile vehicle had not been properly assessed, that employees had not been given suitable instructions on when a truck should be recovered rather than repaired at the roadside, and that Mr Fawcett had not been monitored or supervised. He had obtained his commercial roadside tyre licence less than four months before his death.
My thoughts are with his family. For employers, the case also raises practical questions about how safety arrangements and insurance reviews work when employees are mobile and new to a job.
This develops a point in our recent article on new construction workers and employers’ liability gaps: a new starter may hold a qualification, but supervision is what helps ensure they can work safely in the conditions they actually face.
1. Mobile workers still need active protection
Employers’ liability responsibilities do not stop at the workshop door. If an employee is sent to a roadside location, a customer’s premises or another temporary worksite, the employer still needs to consider the risks and take reasonable steps to protect them.
The location may make a job harder to control, but it does not transfer the employer’s safety responsibilities elsewhere. Nor does an insurance policy supervise a worker, check a lifting method or decide whether a repair is safe to carry out.
For fleet and roadside businesses, I think that distinction is worth making explicit. Insurance is part of managing the financial consequences of an incident; it is not a substitute for safe systems of work. Employers should make sure their instructions cover the real conditions their mobile teams encounter, including the authority to stop work and seek help.
2. Keep competence records useful and current
Records of licences, training, experience and sign-off can help an employer show what a worker was trained to do and what support they received. They are also practical management tools: they help identify who is qualified for a task, when a refresher is due and where closer oversight is needed.
In this case, the timing matters. Mr Fawcett had been licensed for roadside commercial tyre work for less than four months. That fact alone does not tell us everything about his experience, but it reinforces why a qualification date should trigger a discussion about the support a new worker needs.
Underwriters and claims investigators may ask how competence was checked, communicated and kept up to date. Accurate records do not guarantee a particular insurance outcome, but gaps can make it harder to explain what arrangements were in place. And an employers’ liability claim is only one part of the possible exposure: the criminal fine imposed on the company is not an insurance claim, and employers should not expect a policy to fund a criminal fine imposed for their own wrongdoing.
3. Put recover-versus-repair decisions in writing
The HSE found that employees had not been given suitable instructions on when a truck should be recovered rather than repaired at the roadside. This is an important operational gap. A worker should not have to make a high-stakes decision alone, under pressure, without clear guidance on when to stop.
A written escalation rule can set out when work must not proceed, who to contact and what happens next. It could cover conditions such as an unsuitable location, unstable ground, a vehicle that cannot be safely supported, equipment concerns or a task outside the worker’s competence.
The same principle applies beyond tyre work. Contractors make decisions about whether to lift, hoist, jack or use temporary works, often with changing site conditions. If a task falls outside the planned method, people need to know who can authorise a change and when to pause and reassess. That is a simple control, but it needs to be clear enough to use in the moment.

4. Check equipment, inspection and declared activities
The HSE’s account describes a bottle jack slipping while supporting a low-profile truck. It is a reminder to consider whether the equipment is suitable for the vehicle and task, whether it is used on an appropriate surface, and what other controls are required to prevent a vehicle falling.
Employers should have clear arrangements for selecting, using, checking and maintaining lifting equipment. The exact legal requirements depend on the equipment and how it is used; do not assume a particular inspection regime applies without checking. Where relevant, employers should understand their duties under regulations such as PUWER and LOLER, and ensure equipment is used in line with the manufacturer’s instructions and suitable safe systems of work.
There is an insurance consideration too. Make sure your broker understands the work your business undertakes and the plant or equipment involved. That conversation should include mobile work, roadside repairs, lifting equipment and any changes to your services. The details matter: “vehicle repairs” may not adequately explain the specific risks of roadside commercial tyre work.
For firms reviewing Construction Contractor Insurance, equipment and work activities are part of the wider picture. If your business also needs to consider General Contractor Liability Insurance, Moyak’s general contractor information outlines some of the covers that may be relevant. Policy terms and eligibility vary, so check the details with your broker.
5. Build supervision into the first months
A licence or induction is a starting point, not proof that someone can handle every job safely and independently. New workers need a clear way to ask questions, get help and raise concerns. Supervisors need enough time and authority to observe how the work is being done, not just assume that a signed form means the task is understood.
For mobile teams, that needs careful planning. A supervisor may not be physically present at each job, but the business can still set expectations for check-ins, escalation, job authorisation and review. The right arrangements will depend on the work and the worker’s experience. As confidence and competence develop, supervision can be reviewed rather than simply removed by default.

This is where the previous article on new construction workers connects directly with this case. In both settings, the key question is not only whether training took place, but what supervision was in place afterwards. An employers’ liability insurance review should include how new starters are inducted, monitored and signed off in their first months. After an incident, HSE and insurers may both ask what arrangements existed and whether they were appropriate to the work.
Practical next steps
Review your risk assessments and work instructions for mobile tasks. Set a clear recover-versus-repair threshold, make sure workers know how to stop and escalate a job, and check that your supervision matches each person’s experience. Keep licence, training and equipment records current, and discuss any changes to your activities or workforce with your broker.
For construction firms, those checks can sit alongside a broader review of commercial combined insurance, where appropriate. The right cover depends on the business, its activities and the policy wording; no single policy replaces sound safety management.
Moyak Insurance Services works with businesses in Essex, Kent and London to help arrange cover suited to their work and budget. Whether your team works on construction sites or out on the road, speak to your broker about your activities, workers and equipment, and make sure your safety arrangements keep pace with the work.
Source: HSE prosecution release, 4 November 2026. See also the HSE guidance Health and safety in motor vehicle repair and associated industries (HSG261).