📞 01375 392 087  ·  ✉ info@moyakinsurance.co.uk

Mon–Fri: 9:30am – 5:30pm

One Missed Precaution Can Void the Cover: What the Attleys Roofing v QBE Ruling Means for Hot Works

Yesterday, we looked at a Staines roof fire where hot works procedures existed on paper but were not followed. Today’s case takes that same gap between procedure and practice into the courtroom. In Attleys Roofing Limited v QBE UK Limited [2026] EWHC 2742 (Comm), the High Court considered what can happen when a contractor does not follow the specific hot works precautions in its insurance policy.

The practical warning is serious, but it needs to be stated accurately: the court interpreted the wording of this particular policy. It did not establish that every missed precaution automatically removes cover under every insurance policy, nor did it decide every issue affecting Attleys’ ultimate indemnity.

1. What the court decided

On 27 April 2023, Attleys Roofing carried out roofing work at a building known as “the Bank” at Horris Hill Preparatory School in Newbury. Workers used an oxyacetylene torch on lead detailing. After the work had finished, a fire broke out and caused significant damage.

The freeholder and leaseholder threatened claims. Attleys sought indemnity under its QBE Advantage Contractors Liability policy, but QBE denied cover. The dispute turned on the meaning of clause 6.5.4, headed “Heat away from premises – CONDITIONS PRECEDENT”.

The clause applied to work involving a naked flame, heat source, oxyacetylene equipment, or equipment used for welding, cutting, grinding or producing sparks. It set out specific fire-safety precautions. Attleys argued that the phrase “reasonable precautions” should be read in line with the established approach to conventional reasonable-precautions clauses: generally, a failure must be reckless before it can defeat cover. QBE argued that this clause made its listed safeguards conditions of indemnity.

His Honour Judge Pearce accepted QBE’s interpretation at a preliminary hearing on 10 March 2026. Judgment was handed down on 26 October 2026. On the policy wording before him, negligent or even innocent failure to take a specified precaution could engage the condition; recklessness was not required.

That is a significant interpretation, but it is not the same as a final decision that QBE owes nothing. The preliminary issue was about what the clause meant. Whether any relevant precaution was breached, and the further effect of section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015, were not decided at that hearing. The judgment can be read here.

Roofer carrying out hot works while a fire watcher stands by with an extinguisher

2. Treat the hot works list as an operating requirement

The clause required the insured, employees and relevant people acting on its behalf to take specified precautions. In practical terms, these included:

  • appointing a person responsible for fire safety before work began;
  • making workers aware of where fire alarms and firefighting equipment were;
  • examining the area within six metres of the heat source and removing combustible material where reasonably practicable;
  • following the precautions and systems of work in the hot work permit;
  • keeping a fire watcher present while the equipment was being used, with firefighting equipment immediately available; and
  • continuously monitoring the area for one hour after work stopped.

These are not simply reminders to look at after an incident. If a policy sets them out as conditions precedent, they need to be built into the way the job is planned, supervised and recorded.

That means checking the details before work starts: who is responsible for fire safety, who will watch, which equipment is available, what the permit requires and who will remain for the post-work watch. A document can be complete while site practice falls short, so the arrangements need to work in real conditions as well as on paper.

3. Do not assume an innocent mistake is harmless

The decision matters because contractors may assume that a “reasonable precautions” requirement only affects cover where someone has acted recklessly. The court accepted that this expression has an established meaning in insurance law, but found that the wording and context of this clause pointed elsewhere.

The listed safeguards were tied to the phrase “reasonable precautions”. The judge considered that reading “reasonable” both as describing the precautions and as importing a separate recklessness threshold would give it two different functions within the same clause. The wording also referred to subcontractors and others acting on the insured’s behalf. The court saw no convincing commercial reason to treat an identical failure differently depending on whether it was the contractor or a subcontractor who made it.

The result is a reminder to check the precise wording rather than rely on a general impression of what a reasonable-precautions clause usually means. It is especially relevant where a contractor uses labour-only subcontractors or relies on others to supervise a site. Delegating the task does not necessarily remove the contractor’s exposure under the policy.

Hot work permit checklist with completed tick boxes and a one-hour stopwatch

4. Keep records that reflect what actually happened

Records do not replace safe working, and they do not guarantee a claim will be paid. But if compliance is disputed, clear contemporaneous records can help show what arrangements were in place and what was done.

For each hot works job, consider keeping a record of:

  • the named fire-safety lead and fire watcher;
  • the completed permit and any changes made during the job;
  • the six-metre area check, including photographs where useful;
  • the location and availability of firefighting equipment;
  • the briefing given to employees and subcontractors; and
  • the start and finish times of the post-work monitoring.

A signed tick box is not much help if it does not match site reality. Keep the process straightforward enough that the people doing the work can use it consistently, and make sure someone is responsible for checking that it has been followed.

For businesses reviewing their wider Construction Contractor Insurance, hot works wording deserves specific attention alongside the usual questions about liability limits, contract works and subcontractors. The same applies when considering General Contractor Liability Insurance or a wider commercial combined policy: a broad policy heading does not tell you how a particular condition operates.

5. Check your wording before the next job

Start with the policy schedule and wording, not just the certificate. Find the hot works section and look for “conditions precedent”, “reasonable precautions” and any list of required safeguards. Check whether the wording applies to work away from your premises, which people it covers, and what it says about subcontractors.

Then compare the policy requirements against your permit and site procedures. If the policy requires a one-hour watch, make sure the permit and staffing arrangements allow for it. If a six-metre check is specified, ensure the person completing it understands the area to inspect and how combustible materials should be dealt with where reasonably practicable.

Ask your broker to walk through the clause with you and explain any gaps between the policy and your current process. Wording differs between insurers and policies, and this ruling was about one policy’s wording. It should not be treated as a universal rule that every missed precaution in every policy automatically voids cover. This is not legal advice; if you have a live coverage dispute, speak with your broker and a legal adviser.

Judge’s gavel resting on an insurance policy with an orange ribbon bookmark

The practical point is simple: do not wait for a claim to find out whether your hot works procedure matches your insurance condition. Review the wording, brief the people doing the work, make the permit usable on site and keep records of what was actually done. For businesses seeking Business Insurance Essex or Business Insurance London, a broker can help review how the terms fit the work you carry out and the way your teams operate.