Important caveat: The High Court has not decided whether Attleys Roofing actually failed to follow the precautions in its policy, or whether section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 prevents QBE from relying on any failure. The ruling so far concerns how the policy wording should be interpreted. It does not mean that QBE has finally established that the claim is uninsured.
A fire can start after the tools are packed away. For contractors who use torches, welding equipment or other heat sources, that gap between finishing work and leaving site is a practical safety issue, and, as a recent High Court ruling shows, it can also become an insurance issue.
In Attleys Roofing v QBE UK Limited, decided on 26 October 2026, Judge Pearce considered a contractors’ liability policy that listed fire precautions as “conditions precedent”. The court found that the specified measures required strict compliance: an innocent or negligent failure could put cover at risk, not only a reckless one. The ICLG report on the ruling explains the decision and the issues still to be determined.
Here are the practical points contractors should take from it.
1. Read the whole hot-works clause, not just “reasonable precautions”
The case arose from lead-roofing work at Horris Hill Preparatory School in Newbury on 27 April 2023. Attleys Roofing used an oxyacetylene torch. A fire broke out after the work had finished, causing substantial damage.
The policy required “reasonable precautions” when using naked flames or other heat sources, and then specified measures to be taken. These included appointing someone responsible for fire safety, checking the surrounding area for combustible materials, providing firefighting equipment, and continuously monitoring the work area for an hour after completion.
Attleys argued that the usual understanding of a general “reasonable precautions” clause applied to the listed measures too. That understanding is that such a general clause is ordinarily breached only by reckless conduct, rather than an innocent mistake or ordinary carelessness.
QBE argued that the specific measures were absolute requirements. Judge Pearce accepted QBE’s interpretation on this preliminary issue. The distinction matters: when a policy spells out particular precautions and makes them conditions precedent, it may be unsafe to assume that an honest mistake is excused.
2. Check what your policy calls a “condition precedent”
A condition precedent is a term that must be met before the insurer is obliged to provide cover, subject to the policy and the law. In practical terms, if a policy labels a fire-safety requirement this way, contractors should not treat it as a general aspiration or a best-practice suggestion.
Look through the policy wording, schedule and endorsements for sections covering hot works, naked flames, welding, roofing or heat applications. Pay attention to the exact actions required, who must carry them out, and how long monitoring must continue.
If the wording is unclear, ask your broker or insurer to explain it in writing before the next job. The point is not to assume the harshest possible interpretation of every clause, but to understand the specific obligations your policy actually sets.
3. Name the person responsible for fire safety
The policy in the case required someone to be appointed as responsible for fire safety. On site, that responsibility should be clear before hot work starts. Avoid relying on an informal assumption that “someone will keep an eye on it”.
Confirm the person’s role with the team and make sure they understand what they are expected to check and when. If responsibilities change during a job, update the arrangements rather than leaving a gap.
This is especially important where subcontractors are involved. Make sure everyone understands who is responsible for the fire watch and that your arrangements align with the relevant policy requirements.
4. Clear combustible materials and inspect the surrounding area
Before starting, check the immediate work area and its surroundings for combustible materials. Look beyond the spot where the torch is being used: heat and sparks can travel, and fire may take hold out of sight.
Include this check in your hot-work process, and record that it has been completed. If materials cannot be moved, consider what other controls are required before work begins. The court’s decision makes clear why a listed inspection should be treated as an operational step, not a box to tick after the event.

5. Keep suitable firefighting equipment available
The policy required firefighting equipment to be provided. Make sure the equipment is accessible to the people doing the work and that they know where it is. Equipment stored elsewhere on site may not be practical when it is needed quickly.
Check the requirements in your policy and the site’s own safety procedures. Do not assume that having an extinguisher somewhere nearby automatically meets the policy wording.
6. Do not end the fire watch when the torch is switched off
The policy in this case required continuous monitoring of the work area for one hour after the work finished. That requirement is a reminder that the job is not necessarily over when the hot work stops.
Plan the post-work watch into the job rather than leaving it to whoever happens to remain on site. Record who carried it out, when monitoring began and ended, and any relevant checks or concerns. Where a policy specifies a duration, follow the wording and do not substitute a shorter period without confirming that it is acceptable.

7. Keep records that show what was done
A procedure is more useful when there is a reliable record that it was followed. Use a hot-work permit, checklist or site log to note the named fire-safety person, the inspection of the surrounding area, the equipment provided and the post-work monitoring.
Keep records proportionate and practical. A simple, completed checklist can help everyone follow the same routine and may be useful if questions are later raised about the work. Make sure subcontractors understand the process too, and retain records in a place where they can be found.
8. Ask how the wording applies to your actual work
This ruling concerned particular policy wording. It does not mean that every policy has the same requirements, or that every breach automatically leads to a claim being refused. The case has not yet resolved whether Attleys breached the measures or whether QBE can rely on any breach.
Section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 may also be relevant. In broad terms, it can restrict an insurer’s ability to rely on a breach of a risk-reduction term where the breach could not have increased the risk of the loss that actually occurred. The court has not yet decided whether section 11 applies in this dispute. Contractors should therefore avoid treating the preliminary ruling as a final decision on the claim.
For practical help reviewing your policy and how it fits your work, see our guides to choosing construction contractor insurance and the contractors’ insurance clause that could leave you uncovered.
9. Make the policy review part of the job
Before renewing cover or starting work involving heat, check whether the policy’s fire precautions match the way your team operates. Ask your broker to explain any condition precedent in plain language, including how it applies to subcontractors and what evidence you should keep.
At Moyak Insurance Services, we know contractors need insurance that reflects the work they actually do, not just a generic description of their trade. If you would like to review your arrangements, we can discuss Construction Contractor Insurance and support businesses looking for Business Insurance Essex or Business Insurance London. A clear conversation about policy wording and site procedures is a sensible next step.