📞 01375 392 087  ·  ✉ info@moyakinsurance.co.uk

Mon–Fri: 9:30am – 5:30pm

£46.5m Remediation Order: 5 Insurance Lessons from the Urban Splash Tribunal Ruling

The First-tier Tribunal’s decision on 5 November 2026 is a sharp reminder that building-safety costs can return to the businesses involved in a development long after the work is complete. Five companies linked to Urban Splash were ordered to contribute £46.5 million towards remediation across seven Manchester residential developments built between 2000 and 2008.

The buildings had been repaired at a cost of more than £60 million. About £51.1 million came from the government’s Building Safety Fund (BSF). Urban Splash did not own the buildings when the work took place and did not receive BSF money, but the Department of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) pursued a contribution through the specialist tribunal.

This is the retrospective money-lag reality behind the prospective measures discussed in our earlier article on the Remediation of Unsafe Cladding Bill and insurance checks: funding may be provided to get work moving, then government may seek to recover costs from those it considers responsible. The tribunal’s ruling is specific to its facts and is a First-tier Tribunal decision. Urban Splash is reviewing it and taking legal advice, and may appeal.

For contractors, developers and refurbishment specialists, I think there are five practical insurance lessons worth taking from it.

1. Historic work can matter, even after ownership changes

The buildings had been sold before remediation, yet the tribunal still ordered the Urban Splash companies to contribute. Its decision was not based on who owned the properties when the repairs happened, but on the companies’ involvement in the original developments and the statutory route MHCLG used to seek payment.

The decision does not mean every firm involved in a historic project will automatically be liable. Each case depends on its facts and the relevant legal tests. But if your business built, designed or refurbished high-rise residential buildings in the 2000s, a change of owner does not, by itself, mean your historic role can never be examined.

Start by mapping older projects and what your business did on them. Note the dates, your contractual role, the people and companies involved, and the insurance arrangements that may relate to that work. Our guide to Construction Contractor Insurance is a useful starting point for reviewing how cover fits the work you undertake.

2. Building Safety Fund payments may not be the end of the matter

The BSF paid about £51.1 million towards remediation, while MHCLG then pursued a contribution through the tribunal. In this case, the tribunal ordered five companies linked to Urban Splash to pay £46.5 million.

It would be misleading to call the fund a loan in the usual sense. But for businesses involved in historic work, the practical point is similar: the fact a public scheme paid for remediation does not necessarily mean the question of who ultimately bears the cost is settled. Nor does it automatically settle any separate questions about other parties’ liability or insurance.

Keep a clear record of any funding, remediation agreements, settlement discussions and payments connected to your projects. If your business receives a request for information or a contribution demand, do not assume a funding scheme or a building’s current ownership answers the insurance question. Check the relevant policy wording and notification requirements.

Hand-drawn tribunal desk with a gavel, stacked documents and a residential tower model, accented with a subtle orange ribbon

3. Co-operation is important, but it does not decide who pays

The tribunal recognised that Urban Splash had provided “useful and responsible assistance” with post-Grenfell investigations. It also drew a clear distinction between helping investigations and accepting financial responsibility for the resulting remediation.

That is a sensible distinction for any business facing a building-safety concern. Providing records, responding to questions and helping address resident concerns may be appropriate, but co-operation alone does not settle liability or confirm whether insurance will respond. Equally, a firm should not assume that engagement means it has accepted responsibility.

If you receive defect-related correspondence, preserve it and follow your policy’s notification process. Speak to your legal adviser and broker before making commitments about liability, costs or settlement. Early communication gives them a better chance to assess the situation while the details are still clear.

4. Multiple defects can mean a complex chain of responsibility

The tribunal found fire-safety-related defects in each building, including combinations of combustible materials and ineffective cavity barriers. The wider decision also considered issues such as fire-stopping and compartmentation. That matters because a building defect may involve more than one product, trade or decision.

For a contractor, the practical questions may include who specified the materials, who supplied them, who installed them, what was inspected and who certified the work. Subcontractor agreements, drawings, product records, site diaries, inspection reports and handover documents can all help show what happened.

Review the insurance positions across the chain, but do not treat different policies as interchangeable. Professional indemnity (PI) may be relevant to design or professional advice, depending on the wording and circumstances. Public liability and General Contractor Liability Insurance address different risks and may be affected by policy terms concerning defective work or property damage. Contractors’ all risks cover is also not a blanket solution for historic defects. Check cover and records together, including subcontractor insurance and any relevant policy exclusions.

Hand-drawn liability chain linking a developer, contractor, subcontractor and building-product supplier, with one link highlighted in orange

5. The scale of a claim makes early insurance checks worthwhile

Urban Splash described the liability as “significant for a business of our size”. A £46.5 million order is an eight-figure exposure. Smaller contractors may face very different circumstances, but the business impact of even a much smaller claim can be serious.

Check whether PI cover for historic work is still in place, what its retroactive date is, and whether any run-off cover applies. Review policy periods and notification duties, especially where cover is claims-made. Do not wait for court papers before asking your broker how a defect report, document request or contribution demand should be handled.

The 10% reduction in the award also needs careful reading. The tribunal considered previous government failures, but stressed that this did not mean government was responsible for 10% of the defects or remediation costs. It should not be treated as a general formula for apportioning future claims.

Hand-drawn sketch of a broker and contractor reviewing a policy schedule, with a high-rise building visible through the window and an orange folder on the desk

Practical next steps

The ruling does not mean that every contractor associated with a high-rise project will face an order. It does show why businesses should not rely on old assumptions about ownership, funding or the age of the work.

Identify relevant historic projects and gather the contracts, drawings, product information, subcontractor records and insurance documents. Check PI retroactive dates, run-off arrangements, exclusions and notification requirements. If you receive correspondence about a possible defect, tell your broker promptly and follow the policy process.

Moyak Insurance Services works with contractors and businesses across Essex, Kent and London to review cover in light of their work and circumstances. Explore our information for general contractors and commercial combined insurance, or arrange a conversation with your broker about your current policies.

Sources: BBC News report on the Urban Splash ruling and Construction Law report.