Competence is becoming more than a qualification check at the start of a job. It is increasingly written into construction contracts as an ongoing promise, with requirements to show that workers can perform the specific work and continue to do so as the project changes.
That shift matters to subcontractors and specialist contractors. A contract may ask you to warrant that your workers are competent and have met dutyholder obligations, or to keep demonstrating competence throughout the project. If a dispute follows, the question may not only be whether the finished work was acceptable. It may also be whether you made the promises in the contract and can evidence how you met them.
The commercial pressure is real, too. On 16 November 2026, Construction News reported that Jon Vanstone, chair of the Industry Competence Committee (ICC), warned that subcontractors who say they cannot safely carry out safety-critical work could be replaced rather than supported. His comments followed the Building Engineering Services Association (BESA) conference in October. (Read the report.)
Here are five points subcontractors should consider before accepting a package or signing a new set of terms.
1. Saying “we can’t do this safely” needs a plan
In a heavily subcontracted market, there may be a commercial cost to saying that a task falls outside your team’s competence. A contractor may bring in someone else rather than help you build the capability. That is an uncomfortable incentive, but it is one specialists should plan for.
The answer is not to accept work you cannot safely deliver. It is to ask clear questions before committing: what exactly is in scope, what conditions will the team be working in, and what skills or supervision will the task require? If additional training, specialist input or time is needed, raise it while the package is being priced. Put assumptions and requests for support in writing, rather than relying on an informal conversation once the work is under way.
This also helps avoid a later misunderstanding. A verbal “we can’t do this” on site can be recalled as a failure of competence, even if the real issue was a changed design, missing information or an unsuitable site condition. Be specific about what is preventing the work from proceeding safely and what needs to happen next.
2. A competence clause can be a contractual promise
Competence has moved from guidance and legislation into contract wording. BESA senior legal and commercial adviser Tyler Felix has described it as an ongoing obligation, rather than a one-off checklist at appointment. Some contracts require firms to warrant that workers were competent and had discharged dutyholder obligations. Others require competence to be maintained through the project, with evidence beyond qualifications.
A warranty is a promise made under the contract. If a client alleges that the promise was not met, that can create a contractual dispute and defence costs even where the installed work appears satisfactory. The allegation may be about the promise or the process used, not just a physical defect.
Read the wording carefully. Does it ask you to use reasonable skill and care, or does it promise an absolute outcome? Does it cover named workers, everyone in your supply chain or the whole project period? What evidence must you provide, and how quickly? If the wording is broader than what you can control, discuss it with a legal adviser before signing.
3. The evidence gap is where exposure grows
BESA’s survey, prepared by Barbour ABI and released in October 2026, found that 91 per cent of respondents said their organisations could demonstrate compliance with dutyholder requirements. Yet 36 per cent reported difficulty demonstrating competence in practice. Only 43 per cent used formal competence assessments to verify workers’ capabilities, compared with 90 per cent who relied on qualifications and certificates.
Those figures point to a practical gap. Certificates show that training or assessment took place at some point; on their own, they do not show whether a person was assessed against the task they are doing today. BESA chief executive David Frise has also said member audits sometimes uncover differences between a firm’s stated procedures and what happens in practice. BESA reported suspending five firms after failed audit checks in January 2026, following 14 suspensions in 2025.
For a specialist contractor, the useful question is not simply “Do we have the certificates?” It is “Can we show who was assessed, for which task, under what conditions, and what happened when those conditions changed?”

4. Start with the role, and treat change as a trigger
Vanstone’s advice was to start competence management with the role, not the person. In practice, that means considering what a particular task demands, who is assigned to it, what supervision is needed and whether the working conditions match the plan.
Change should prompt a fresh look. A product substitution, a design revision or a site condition that differs from the drawings can alter what the task requires. Fire-stopping is a clear example: an installer may arrive to find that the opening or surrounding construction does not match the approved detail.
BESA’s Brian Hughes warned that deadline pressure can discourage workers from stopping to question a problem. But knowing when to pause and say “this isn’t right” is part of responsible work. Record the issue, who was notified, the instruction received and the agreed way forward. Unrecorded deviations can leave specialists exposed when the parties later disagree about what was installed or why.

5. Check what your insurance responds to
Competence obligations can affect how insurers assess a business and how a claim is considered. Professional indemnity and liability insurers may ask about competence management and quality assurance as well as qualifications. More importantly, a contract can make you responsible for promises that are wider than the cover you expect to rely on.
Professional indemnity policies commonly respond to particular forms of professional liability, subject to their terms. Public or general liability insurance is generally aimed at specified legal liabilities for injury or property damage. Neither label, by itself, confirms that a contractual competence warranty is covered. The wording of the contract and the policy matters, and an insurer may not cover a liability you accepted simply by promising a particular result.
Before signing, tell your broker what work you actually do and share the relevant contract wording. Ask whether the promises you are making could create liability beyond your usual negligence-based exposure, and whether your policy responds to the kinds of allegations that might follow. Cover is subject to the policy terms, conditions and exclusions, so do not assume that a certificate of insurance settles the question.
Moyak’s construction contractor insurance guide explains why cover should reflect the work you carry out. Contractors can also review our information on general contractors and commercial combined insurance. These pages are a starting point; your actual requirements depend on your business and policy wording.

Practical next steps
Before you accept a package or renew a contract, check that the scope, competence promises and evidence requirements match what your team can deliver. Assess workers against their actual tasks, not only their certificates. Agree how substitutions, changed products, design revisions and unexpected site conditions will be reviewed and recorded.
Keep the assessment and change-control trail, along with a clear record of deviations and instructions. Then share your real work and any competence warranties with your broker and legal adviser before signing. That is relevant whether you are arranging Construction Contractor Insurance, reviewing General Contractor Liability Insurance or seeking Business Insurance Essex or Business Insurance London.
I think the industry needs contracts that make it practical to stop, raise a concern and get the right support, rather than rewarding “just get it done” behaviour. For subcontractors, the immediate step is to make sure competence promises are clear, evidenced and considered alongside the insurance before the work begins.