The words “PCI to be inserted” are short, but they raise a practical question: what is a safety plan worth if it still contains a reminder to complete it?
That question is at the centre of prosecution evidence reported by Construction News on 12 November 2026 in the ongoing corporate manslaughter trial of Higgins Homes at the Old Bailey. The prosecution’s expert witness, Craig Hook, told the court that construction management and phase plans used for the Bow site were generic and contained errors and omissions. These are allegations and evidence presented in court, not findings of guilt.
Higgins Homes denies corporate manslaughter and a breach of Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. Four individuals also deny the charges against them. Nothing has been decided.
The case concerns Michaela Boor, who was 28 when she was struck by a pallet of bricks that fell from a tower crane while she was walking past a residential site on Burdett Avenue, Bow, on 27 March 2018. She died two days later, the day after her 29th birthday. Her death deserves to be treated with respect. The lessons below concern the prosecution’s account of safety paperwork and the need for plans to reflect actual site conditions.
1. A plan needs to be specific to the job
According to the report, the construction phase health and safety plan’s section for pre-construction information from the client ended in the final version with the words “PCI to be inserted”. A table intended to identify people at risk from specific issues was also incomplete, with one box left blank.
Hook told the court that a useful document needs to consider the risks at that location, the work being done, the equipment and materials being used, and how those factors come together. That is a straightforward test for any contractor reviewing a plan: could someone use it to understand the risks and controls on this site, or could the same document be filed for almost any job?
The lesson illustrated by the prosecution’s evidence is that a plan can look complete at a glance while missing information that matters. A sign-off should involve checking the actual details, not just confirming that a document exists. If information is missing, identify who will supply it and resolve the gap before it is relied upon.

2. Look for contradictions and “ghost” details
The court heard that the plan referred to Booker Close in two places with contradictory instructions: one reportedly said vehicles should not use it, while another said they should reverse there. It also listed equipment and controls (including mast climbers, a slew limitation system and fans over scaffold railings) that Hook said were not used on site.
The traffic management plan, the court heard, described one-way traffic management, on-site parking and a wheel-washing station that were not in place. It also showed access from “Saxon Way”, which the report says does not exist in the area. The construction plan reportedly cited the superseded CDM 2007 regulations, despite mentioning the 2015 regulations elsewhere.
These details are not proof of the charges. They are, however, useful prompts for a document review. Check that road names, site access, plant, protective equipment and control measures are real and current. Read the plan for contradictions, not just spelling errors. A document describing arrangements that do not exist can confuse the people expected to follow it and undermine confidence that the risks have been properly considered.
3. Revision is not the same as review
Hook told the court that although the document had been revised, he saw no independent risk check and no monitoring of whether it was adequate. He described fundamentals as missing.
Under the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015, a principal contractor must draw up, or arrange for the drawing up of, a construction phase plan before the site is set up, and ensure it is appropriately reviewed, updated and revised during the project. The HSE’s guidance for principal contractors also explains their role in planning, managing and monitoring the construction phase.
In practice, that means checking whether the plan still matches the work as it changes: the people on site, sequence, access, equipment and controls. A new version number alone does not show that anyone tested the plan against those realities. It helps to name a reviewer, record what changed, and make clear who needs to be briefed.

4. Make the procurement decision match the site controls
The prosecution’s account also described crane-planning emails and a quotation. A November 2016 request for a quote to London Tower Cranes included a diagram showing a pedestrian gantry and a line limiting crane movement. The quote included prices for an anti-collision or zoning system and a hook camera. A December email from Higgins contracts manager Ben Richardson said the crane needed to be restricted so it would not oversail the site.
Hook told the court that it did not appear the anti-collision system or hook camera were taken up when the order was placed, and that no gantry was installed. These are points in the prosecution’s evidence, not a determination by the court.
The broader procurement lesson is practical: safety options discussed in planning need to be traced through to the order and then checked on site. If a priced control is not selected, record the decision and what alternative control will manage the risk. A safety feature listed in a quote does not protect anyone if it is not supplied and used.

5. Paperwork matters to insurance, but it is not a substitute for safety
The charges in this case are criminal allegations, and criminal fines or criminal liability are not something a business should expect to insure away. Separate civil claims by third parties raise different questions. Whether public liability insurance responds depends on the policy wording, declared activities, exclusions and circumstances. Crane operations, work at height, contract requirements and the way the site is actually managed may all be relevant to an insurer’s assessment.
That does not mean a paperwork problem automatically removes cover. Policies differ, and the effect of any condition or exclusion depends on its wording and the facts. But documents that do not match the site are likely to attract scrutiny after an incident, from investigators and potentially from insurers handling a claim.
For a related example of why policy wording and records matter, see our article on hot works conditions and the Attleys Roofing v QBE ruling. Contractors reviewing Construction Contractor Insurance or General Contractor Liability Insurance should make sure their broker understands the work they actually undertake, including crane and lifting operations where relevant. A commercial combined policy may bring several covers together, but the schedule and wording still need to fit the business.
For businesses seeking Business Insurance Essex or Business Insurance London, the same principle applies: tell your broker what happens on site, not just what the business is called. If you have a live legal or insurance issue, speak with your legal adviser and broker.
Practical checks for your next site
Before work starts, have someone independent of the original drafter check the plan against the actual site. Complete missing information, remove outdated details and resolve contradictions. Compare traffic arrangements, plant, lifting controls and protective measures with what has been ordered and installed. When something changes, update the plan and tell the people who need to act on it.
The Higgins Homes trial is ongoing, and the defendants deny the charges. The prosecution’s evidence nevertheless offers a clear prompt for contractors, principal designers and site managers: paperwork should describe the site you have, the work you are doing and the controls that are genuinely in place. Otherwise, it risks becoming a filing exercise rather than a practical safety tool.