📞 01375 392 087  Â·  âś‰ info@moyakinsurance.co.uk

Mon–Fri: 9:30am – 5:30pm

The LEG Defect Clauses Have Been Rewritten for the First Time in 20 Years: What It Means for Your Contractors All Risks Cover

The wording in your contract works policy can make a significant difference when a construction defect leads to damage. The London Engineering Group (LEG) has now published revised model defect exclusion clauses: LEG 1/26, LEG 2/26 and LEG 3/26. For contractors and developers, the practical question is which wording applies to your policy and what it means for the work you are taking on.

1. What the LEG clauses are and what has changed

LEG’s model defect exclusions are used in contractors all risks (CAR) and engineering all risks (EAR) policies. They address how cover applies when a defect in materials, workmanship or design is connected with damage to insured property.

The clauses have been in use in international markets since 1996. The latest versions, published on 10 November 2026 under the International Underwriting Association’s (IUA) aegis, replace the /96 and /06 wordings. LEG 3/06 was the last version to be revised, in 2006. The new clauses were formally launched at Lloyd’s Old Library after LEG became affiliated with the IUA in July.

The update follows two US court decisions in 2023 and 2024 that described the old LEG 3 wording as “egregiously ambiguous” and “internally inconsistent”. The courts found that the language did not clearly exclude the claims before them. After those decisions, a significant number of insurers withdrew LEG 3 from US construction risks, with many reverting to “cost of making good” endorsements. LEG 3 cover remained available in the London market for international risks.

The underlying intent of the clauses has not changed. What is new is the /26 wording and, for the first time, accompanying explanatory commentary published alongside it. The clauses and commentary are available through the IUA clauses database.

One point is particularly important for policyholders: an existing policy written on LEG /96 or /06 terms remains subject to those terms. The /26 wordings are relevant to new placements, so the difference is worth discussing when you renew, tender or restructure your cover.

2. The sliding scale, in plain English

The three clauses provide different levels of cover in relation to damage caused by a defect. Broadly, the scale runs from the strictest exclusion under LEG 1/26 to the narrower exclusion under LEG 3/26.

An inspector examines a crack in a building under construction

  • LEG 1/26 is the strictest option. It provides an absolute exclusion for damage caused by a defect.
  • LEG 2/26 excludes the cost that would have been incurred to replace or rectify the defective property if the defect had been found before damage occurred.
  • LEG 3/26 has a narrower exclusion and attracts a higher premium. It removes only the additional cost of improving the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification used for the defective property.

The practical difference can be substantial. Imagine a problem with a component in a building that leads to damage beyond the original faulty work. Depending on the wording, the insurer may consider both the cost of correcting the defect and the resulting damage. Under LEG 2/26, for example, the relevant exclusion focuses on what it would have cost to rectify the defective property before damage occurred. LEG 3/26 focuses on the additional cost of improving the defective work or materials.

That is not a promise that a particular claim will be paid. The facts, policy wording, exclusions and other terms all matter. But on a real job, the choice between these clauses can affect whether the insurer excludes a broad part of the loss or only a narrower element. It is not a detail to leave until a claim arrives.

For a contractor buying Construction Contractor Insurance, the right question is not simply “Do I have contract works cover?” It is also “Which defect exclusion is attached, and how does it interact with the work I do?”

3. Why “damage” versus “defect” is the fault line

The difficult question behind many defect disputes is where a defect ends and damage begins. A defect might be poor workmanship, a faulty design or unsuitable materials. Damage generally refers to a physical change to property that affects its value or usefulness. The distinction matters because a CAR policy is not normally intended to be a maintenance or quality guarantee for the cost of putting defective work right.

A balance scale contrasts a building defect with physical damage, with an orange arrow pointing towards damage

The US cases exposed how the old LEG 3 language could be argued over, including what counted as “damage” and what “improvement” meant in the exclusion. Those are not abstract questions when repair costs are mounting and several parties are trying to establish who should pay.

English law has a more defined position following the 2024 Court of Appeal decision in Sky UK Ltd and Mace Ltd v Riverstone Managing Agency Ltd. The ruling confirmed that, under English law, damage requires an adverse physical change that impairs a property’s value or usefulness. Insurers have since been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, so the definition may be reviewed further.

I think that is a good reason to avoid relying on a general description of “all risks” cover. A policy schedule may say one thing in broad terms, but the endorsements and exclusions decide how the cover responds to a particular loss.

4. What to check before renewal

Before you renew or take on a project with specific insurance requirements, ask your broker to confirm which LEG version appears in your contract works policy. Look for /96, /06 or /26 in the policy endorsements, and ask for a plain-English explanation of what the relevant clause excludes.

If you are tendering for work, check the insurance requirements in the contract early. A requirement to carry CAR or EAR cover does not, by itself, tell you which defect wording is in place or whether it matches the project’s expectations. If you are restructuring cover, remember that the /26 clauses are the revised wordings to discuss for new placements, while existing policies remain on their current terms.

Keep in mind that workmanship is not what CAR is designed to guarantee. The aim is not to insure every cost of correcting a contractor’s own faulty work. But understanding where the exclusion line sits can help you assess the risk, explain responsibilities in a contract and reduce the chance of a dispute later.

If you are comparing cover, our information for general contractors explains some of the policy areas contractors commonly consider. Businesses reviewing wider protection can also see the scope of commercial combined insurance, though the suitability of any policy depends on the business and the specific cover arranged.

5. The claims angle: late discovery can be expensive

Defects discovered late can be particularly costly. By then, the question is often no longer just what it costs to correct the original fault. There may also be damage to other property, delay, access costs and questions about how the defect developed. The policy’s defect exclusion can become central to working out which parts of the loss may be covered.

A broker and contractor review a contract works schedule and three LEG clause options

Contractors can help themselves by keeping clear records of materials, inspections, design decisions and workmanship. Those records do not determine cover, but they can help establish what happened and when. If an issue emerges, notify the relevant parties and speak to your broker promptly rather than assuming the whole loss is either covered or excluded.

For subcontractors, it is also worth checking whether your own insurance meets the requirements of the main contract. General Contractor Liability Insurance and contract works cover address different risks, and a liability certificate alone may not answer questions about damage to the works themselves.

Practical next steps

The LEG update does not automatically rewrite your current policy, but it gives contractors and brokers new wording to consider for future placements. Before your next renewal, check the LEG version on your schedule, ask what it means for your work and confirm that the cover meets any project requirements. If you are uncertain, speak to your broker while there is still time to compare options and address gaps.